| Support Center
  • Cristiane Incer
  • September 27, 2024
  • 4 min read

Yelp Reviews: Hidden Gem or Wasted Time?

Managing your online reputation might seem like another thing to add to your already packed schedule. But think of it like taking care of your tools—if you keep them in good shape, they’ll serve you well. Keeping an eye on your online reviews is key to getting new customers and building trust with the ones you’ve got. But with many review platforms available, it can be tough to know where to focus your efforts. 

One common question we hear is: “Are Yelp reviews worth my time?” Let’s break it down so you can decide what’s best for your business.

Why Reviews Matter

Imagine you’re John, a local plumber who’s great at fixing pipes… One day, after finishing a job, a customer leaves you a glowing 5-star review on Google. A few days later, you notice your phone starts ringing more often and you land a few extra jobs! That’s the power of a good review. And it could work the same magic for your business!

Reviews are the modern-day word-of-mouth. They help potential customers decide whether to choose your business and even influence how easily people can find you online. The more positive reviews you get on your Google Business Profile (GBP), the better your business will show up when people search for services like yours. It’s like giving your business a little nudge so that when folks are looking for what you offer, your name pops up right where they can see it.

Yelp Reviews: What You Need to Know

Yelp is a review platform you’ve probably heard of if you run a restaurant or service-based business. It’s been around for over 20 years, letting customers share their experiences with your business—good or bad. This can be great for getting noticed and helping people make decisions about where to go.

But it’s not all smooth sailing. Managing reviews can be a real headache, especially if you’re already juggling a million other things. Yelp can help get the word out, but it also comes with its own set of challenges. So, is Yelp worth your time? Let’s break down the pros and cons to help you decide.

PRO- Yelp can boost your business

Since Yelp is well-known, good reviews here can increase your business’s visibility among users who rely on Yelp to find services. It also provides detailed feedback, helping you understand what your customers think about your business. If you’re in a competitive industry, having a strong Yelp presence can make a difference. On the other hand, a strong Yelp profile can enhance trust with potential customers who look for honest reviews there. But it’s not without its issues…

CON- Possible Review Manipulation

Yelp has been accused of manipulating reviews and pressuring businesses into advertising to improve their scores. There’s even a documentary called Billion Dollar Bully that raises concerns about the fairness of Yelp’s review system. Yelp’s system sometimes also hides genuine customer reviews, which means some of your best feedback might not be seen by others. This can be frustrating when you’re trying to showcase your great service. 

Despite these bumps in the road, Yelp only bags a modest 6% of the market share—a blip compared to Google’s whopping 73%! This puts into perspective Yelp’s spot in the review world pecking order, especially when you toss in that Yelp reviews don’t pack the same punch in search engine rankings as Google’s, according to Bright Local’s 2024 Local Consumer Review Survey!

Yelp vs. Google Reviews

Now that we’ve weighed the pros and cons of Yelp, let’s see how it compares to the dominant player in the review space: Google Reviews.

Google Reviews

Yelp Reviews

Tips for Managing Reviews

To effectively manage your business’s online reviews, focusing first on Google Reviews can significantly boost your search visibility. Yelp shouldn’t be entirely overlooked though. If you already have a lot of Google reviews, encouraging happy customers to leave feedback on Yelp can benefit your business as well.

Here’s a simple step-by-step guide to managing reviews:

  • After a job well done: Just finished a great job? While shaking hands with your satisfied customer, ask, “Would you mind leaving a quick review on Google? It really helps!
  • Send a follow-up: A day or two later, send a review request with your Olly Olly App. This gentle reminder can boost your chances of getting that review.
  • Check your reviews: Regularly open our app to monitor new reviews and respond as soon as you get one—whether they’re praise or concerns. Showing that you value customer feedback helps build trust and maintain a positive reputation.

So next time you finish a job and receive that appreciative handshake, don’t hesitate to ask for that review on Google!

How Olly Olly Can Help

Feeling overwhelmed with managing reviews? Let Olly Olly lighten the load. Our app simplifies tracking and responding to reviews, allowing you to focus on what you do best—running your business. With Olly Olly’s support, you can manage your online reputation effortlessly, making sure you never miss a beat.

If you ever need a hand, just reach out to your account manager—they’re here to help. Not an SEO services client yet? Call 877-Olly-Olly today and we’ll make sure your business not only gets found by the right people but also chosen!

Our Commitment to You

At Olly Olly, we’re here to help you manage your online reputation without the stress. We understand that keeping up with reviews and optimizing your Google Business Profile can seem like a lot, so we handle the heavy lifting for you. Our approach is simple: we prioritize genuine connections with your customers, ensuring your business is accurately represented and easy to find.

We’re not looking for shortcuts. We’re here to get you found!

Cristiane   Incer

SEO Content Implementation and Enhancement Manager

Based in Managua, Nicaragua, Cristiane Incer is the SEO Content Implementation and Enhancement Manager at Olly Olly. A natural flair for content creation, coupled with an in-depth understanding of SEO, makes copywriting her true passion.